The mathematical rebellion is real! The equation shows infinity minus infinity equals zero, which looks perfectly logical at first glance. But mathematicians are screaming internally right now because infinity isn't a regular number you can just subtract like that! It's a concept representing something that goes on forever without bound.
In reality, infinity-infinity is what mathematicians call an "indeterminate form" - it could equal literally anything depending on how you approach it. The pirate's conflicted "Well yes, but actually no" response perfectly captures the mathematician's dilemma when someone tries to do arithmetic with infinity. Pure mathematical chaos!